MDK2 pending menu/game request: classifier defect, bounded correction
The contradictory pending scheme rejection published in cf0c275ea is a
demonstrated run-controller defect. The original program can retain applied
menu while requesting game, with the old startscreen Level still present.
The corrected run-owned classifier permits this specific pending request under
the existing post-Medium checks. It authorizes only finite input-free observation;
it establishes neither playable readiness nor eventual successful loading.
No production runtime change is justified or made.
Evidence and small recoverable helper patches are in
scratch/runs/20261104-mdk2-pending-scheme-cause/. Investigation checkout was
484fcd89fffede6d4579fe61a92085aaa0d1d4d5; captured execution remains
1329b1ba6eb00144ff77d4cd92a8513d4fc953ad, with canonical module
cffca869b541e6eff12ae3a6b74c4476977e0a7e23cd43d8ec5ba8faecd4bcee.
inspect-cause.cjs verifies all 422 files in the predecessor's final local seal,
the five relevant capture/PNG hashes, and the executable/scripts archive against
the captured runtime pins. Original media are referenced by existing path and
SHA-256; none are copied.
The original flow explains the pair:
menu.lua:1061–1065selects Medium, sets difficulty 0.35 and invokesmenu.diff.Go. Lines 1080–1087 hide the menu, freeze Level, arm the startscreen timer for 1.2 seconds and start the fade.level0.lua:328–343handles that timer. Selected-zero callsmdkNewGame(1,9)and then assignsnewconscheme = "game". It does not assignconschemeor replace the Lua Level table there.- The executable registers
mdkNewGameto0x4391a0at0x434ea9. Its wrapper calls0x42bbe0, which calls0x42cc80. That function stores requested level/checkpoint at0x4b712c/0x4b7494, sets pending load flag0x5ccb48 = 1, and returns. This is a deferred request, not a synchronous invocation of Lualevel(). - Main-loop code independently dispatches
SetConSchemeat0x401333.menuinit.lua:21–25copies the pending scheme to the applied scheme and clears the pending value. The main loop checks the load flag at0x4019d2, invokes loader0x42c990at0x401a28, and clears the flag. The loader's later0x42cc1epath dispatches the Lua function namedlevel. mdk2.lua:373–398sets both schemes to game, clears Level/Save, then assigns new checkpoint/level/section and loads the next script. Those are subsequent construction facts; they need not exist immediately after the timer request.
original-source-excerpts.json, native-flow.txt and
native-byte-contracts.json preserve selected original lines, disassembly and
eight exact PE byte contracts. Decoded script hashes match prior references.
These are static contracts, not forced execution of guest callbacks. The
captured sequence is consistent with this path; it does not contain an
instruction trace proving precisely where the guest stopped.
| Capture step | Captured native facts |
|---|---|
| 3184 | Highlighted New Game reported in the original personal review; startscreen/title, freeze nil, pending nil. |
| 3232 | Medium reported in its separate personal review; startscreen/menu, showmenu 1, freeze nil, pending nil. |
| 3280 | Medium result: menu hidden, freeze 1, startscreen/menu, pending nil. |
| 3296 | Same pending facts after one input-free quantum. |
| 3312 | Same Lua state and Level identity, level0/checkpoint0, startscreen/menu, freeze1/showmenu0; pending now game. Enter/Escape at native rest. |
captured-sequence.json records exact paths, hashes, timestamps and input
history. I personally viewed the retained 3312 PNG: the game area is black,
with no visible comic/tutorial/playable evidence. This historical view creates
no runtime review or input permission. Resource observations remain unchanged;
the observer does not expose the native level-load request globals above.
Black pixels or elapsed slices alone would not justify the correction.
The change in transition-evidence.cjs keeps the predicate: pending scheme must
be tagged nil or exactly the tagged string game. Its enclosing branch still
requires applied menu, startscreen, freeze1, selected0, current difficulty,
showmenu0, valid Level table, level0/checkpoint0 and no loadscreen, plus original
observer/worker/native command identities, input rest and resource guards.
Title/menu/foreign pending strings and malformed tags still reject. Game/game
construction and game/nil movie boundaries remain unchanged and cannot be used
to claim playability from this state.
pending-control.cjs and phase-gate.cjs are byte-identical to the prior helpers;
their local imports now resolve the corrected classifier. Small control.py
routing edits point both the pending helper and phase gate at this run directory.
next.py is unchanged. No runtime adapter, release authority, browser connection
or launch capability is supplied. A future separately assigned fresh run must
stage and hash-qualify this closure, retain the pinned original runtime and exact
VIEW/review/input-preflight protocol, and use a new output directory. The failed
3312 session and its original failure latch remain untouched; it cannot be
resumed through this correction.
Offline verification:
node scratch/runs/20261104-mdk2-pending-scheme-cause/inspect-cause.cjs
node --test scratch/runs/20261104-mdk2-pending-scheme-cause/test-pending.cjs
python3 scratch/runs/20261104-mdk2-pending-scheme-cause/test-route.py
All 54 controller/classifier controls and six routing controls pass. The actual 3312 JSON rejects under the old classifier and permits only pending observation under the correction, without mutation. A synthetic receipt peer exercises nil-to-game during a quantum and subsequent fresh review. Negatives cover true contradictory/foreign schemes, malformed tags, wrong Level/file/menu effects, held native input, stale review, foreign source/module, premature playable claims, stronger phase routes, faults and preserved first-error latches. Existing ACK/timeout/history/budget tests also pass. Synthetic transport pixels are explicitly synthetic; no native callback is executed by these tests.
The 16-slice quantum, 32 pending quanta / 512 slices / 96 commands, shared
540-second anchor and aggregate construction limits are unchanged. Every quantum
ends at a fresh inspection barrier; exhaustion still stops. Original unchanged
26 unhighlighted/wrapper, 18 scene and five predecessor routing controls are
reused by exact sealed file/hash references in reused-controls.json, rather
than rerun. Changed pending and adapter paths were tested together here.
Only this note is committed. Relevant binary diff, Git SHA, small new-file patches, test logs, dependency hashes and final SHA seal preserve the ignored run helpers without source archives or module/media copies. A full build is inapplicable to the note and ignored helper changes; no production code changed and the sole local heavy lane remained with the Deus Ex worker. No Chrome, heavy CLI, WASM instance, remote/box operation, guest writes, repaint, additional input, subworker, successor or deployment occurred.
No box is assigned to this offline task. Historical bx_ejf8j8yx was returned
to the coordinator with expiry 2026-11-04T11:58:35.973Z. The coordinator's board
entry reports its normal stop completed at 11:37:28.747Z; this worker made no
lifecycle action or fresh API check. Next work, if separately assigned, is a
bounded fresh replay with this exact correction. This assignment stops here.