Penguin Command original static closure: technical review, 2026-10-23

Historical source last updated, 2026-10-23. Runtime and implementation claims below describe that dated source; see current app notes and source for subsequent changes.

ACCEPT scoped static dependency and launch closure. No substantive defect found in producer e83f93fd941f105fa9bc6424346b0e610d36a4bf, branch task/penguin-command-retained-closure-complete-oct23. This accepts an offline launch recipe and provider inventory; it does not qualify execution or gameplay. Worker 01a16a1f-a98b-7171-b2ab-cf4b84eabe8d owns only this new report and adjacent penguin-command-independent-closure-accept-20261023/ evidence on private branch task/penguin-command-independent-closure-accept-oct23, based on that producer.

The producer report and adjacent manifests, verify.py, launch.sh, original README and actual retained images were reviewed read-only. The coordinator's accepted 17 seals were not rerun as a substitute for semantic acceptance. verify.py would write its verification receipt in the donor directory, so it was read, not executed. This review uses independent struct PE parsing and small host helper checks. No downloads, extraction, builds, WebAssembly APIs, guest execution, box access, integration, source or shared-index changes occurred.

Independent review.py reads DOS e_lfanew, PE signature, machine, optional-header magic, data directories, raw-backed section RVA mappings, import descriptors, 32-bit thunk names/ordinal flags, export name/ordinal/function tables and forwarder ranges. independent-pe.json retains these actual fields and complete symbols. It finds 8 original i386 PE32 images, plus the standing CRT, 682 imported symbol edges and zero ordinal imports. The edge multiset independently matches the producer's manifest. Every required native symbol has a nonzero original provider export; none requires a forwarder. Provider identity uses the actual filename, which lib/dll-loader.js:nameMatches supports even where internal export DLL names differ (the SDL/libSDL convention).

The six bundled DLLs are SDL, SDL_image, SDL_mixer, jpeg, libpng12-0 and zlib1. The seventh native provider is the standing msvcrt.dll, 278581 bytes, SHA-256 887eb5ce93edb7192ca3e9220f07f9ca0f94db02af5862ebcbdfcb852db99fd1. Its imports are included in the 682 edges and its exports satisfy the CRT names; API-table absence for a native CRT export is not a missing provider. Required system DLLs are KERNEL32, USER32, GDI32, ADVAPI32 and WINMM. Inventory comparison preserves exactly WINMM.waveOutGetErrorTextA and WINMM.midiStreamStop as unexecuted risks. Other API-table names likewise do not prove implementation or ABI.

SDL_image.dll itself contains nine JPEG and sixteen PNG zero-terminated lookup candidates. The evidence records each original file offset and corresponding provider export RVA/ordinal. All 25 resolve. JPEG/PNG dynamic availability is checked separately from ordinary imports: omitting JPEG can leave the static import walk intact. Strings plus exports do not establish executed LoadLibrary/ GetProcAddress order, loader success, calling convention, structure layouts or decoder correctness. The report's candidate wording is appropriate. No speculative TIFF/Vorbis/SMPEG dependency or new support claim is added.

Rejecting controls remove each of the seven providers, remove zlib's inflate export, and substitute zlib's export table for JPEG's. The combined import and codec-candidate oracle rejects all nine. The first version of this review's omission test used imports alone and correctly demonstrated that removing JPEG does not reject ordinary imports; the test was corrected to cover dynamic candidates before acceptance. This is a test-oracle refinement, not a donor defect.

The direct original EXE is 107008 bytes, SHA-256 14d6e430c26c44c94ef5c176eca2f66edd82dd66fd155d29a5596e3d6e170fc1, entry RVA 0x1290. Its bytes match the same member of the read-only donor ZIP. The separate 32768-byte windowed EXE contains penguin-command --windowed and imports CreateProcessA; the direct EXE does not import CreateProcessA. Directly passing documented flags avoids that wrapper's child-process requirement. Original README-win32.txt documents mouse aiming, A/S/D firing, fullscreen default, --windowed, --nosound, executable-directory CWD, and beside-EXE settings/scores. The original EXE also contains the flags and penguin-command.dat string.

The retained quiet profile mounts all 83 PNG/JPG graphics under data/gfx/, including title.jpg; PNG-only loses graphics. Eight WAV/S3M sound assets are optional for the documented no-sound profile. SDL_mixer remains a required native DLL even with no sound, since import resolution still needs it. Actual no-sound branch reachability, including avoidance of the two WINMM gaps, remains untested. penguin-command.dat is initially absent. CWD C:\ beside the EXE is essential: the host VirtualFS can create/write that relative filename there, but an existing wrong CWD changes its path and would also break relative graphics lookup.

harness.js never imports run.js. It evaluates only the exact getArg/getArgs excerpt, and imports host-only process-boot, VFS inclusion and VirtualFS helpers. It checks 83 actual mounted graphic paths, seven explicit native seeds bypassing registry eligibility, loaded DLL file aliases, argument staging through a tiny mock export callback, and a host VFS create/write. Its graph check deliberately isolates seed admission; PE dependency correctness comes from review.py. Missing-glob, absolute POSIX/Windows include and nonexistent-CWD controls reject; PNG-only and existing-wrong-CWD controls show concrete omissions/path changes. No guest argv or CRT startup was executed. Source review also follows run.js EXTRA_ARGS into setExtraCmdline before stageAndLoadPe, then the WAT command-line/ CRT argv builder's whitespace tokenization. The 20-character argument payload is below the setter's 200-byte limit.

One concrete launch recipe follows. Do not run under this static allocation. The coordinator must assign a qualified prebuilt module, runtime budget and box, and an admitted empty evidence directory. These host paths refer to existing local retention; transfer with the original recovery recipe if running elsewhere.

HARNESS_ROOT=/home/user/wine-assembly
PENGUIN_DATA=/home/user/wine-assembly-penguin-command-retained-closure-oct23/docs/re-notes/penguin-command-retained-closure-20261023/original/penguin-command-1.6.11
PENGUIN_CRT=/home/user/wine-assembly/test/binaries/dlls/msvcrt.dll
: "${QUALIFIED_WASM:?coordinator-qualified prebuilt module}"
: "${RUN_DIR:?admitted empty runtime evidence directory}"
unset WINE_RUN_EXTRA_ARGS
node "$HARNESS_ROOT/test/run.js" --no-build --wasm="$QUALIFIED_WASM" \
  --exe="$PENGUIN_DATA/penguin-command.exe" \
  --exe-guest-path='C:\penguin-command.exe' --cwd='C:\' \
  --args='--windowed --nosound' \
  --dlls="$PENGUIN_CRT,$PENGUIN_DATA/SDL.dll,$PENGUIN_DATA/zlib1.dll,$PENGUIN_DATA/libpng12-0.dll,$PENGUIN_DATA/jpeg.dll,$PENGUIN_DATA/SDL_image.dll,$PENGUIN_DATA/SDL_mixer.dll" \
  --vfs-include='data/gfx/*.png' --vfs-include='data/gfx/*.jpg' \
  --quiet-api --no-close --max-seconds=60 --max-batches=200000 \
  --control-stdin --png="$RUN_DIR/exit.png" \
  --save-vfs="$RUN_DIR/vfs" --save-vfs-suffix=.dat

This uses the actual run.js explicit --dlls branch: comma-split native files, then mountLoadedDllFiles/loadDlls. It intentionally supplies the complete seven providers because that branch bypasses recursive graph discovery. The producer's seven repeated --dll-seed flags are also valid: absolute paths survive appAsset, seeds bypass isLoadableDll and mount the same providers. Repeated graphics flags are supported; the helper also supports comma-separated values. Quoting preserves the guest argument string. The producer launch.sh passes sh -n. Mounted asset paths become C:\data\gfx..., EXE identity is C:\penguin-command.exe, and CWD is applied after mounts. Writable VFS, rather than the host donor directory, holds future configuration writes. Saving VFS on host termination does not prove the game's ordinary save/exit path.

Remaining original runtime acceptance is concrete: reach and inspect title/menu; select the observed Normal Game entry using ordinary input; mouse aim at two positions and press/release A/S/D to fire ordinary cannons; capture enemy movement, player missile trajectory/explosion, changing score and wave progression across meaningfully separated frames. Preserve actual first faults, API/EIP traces and module identity. Check SDL video/event/timer behavior, native CRT startup, dynamic JPEG/PNG decoding and no-sound reachability. Test ordinary exit/relaunch persistence if claiming saved configuration/scores. No screenshot or gameplay claim is made here.