Shadow Man declaration-law technical review: blocked (2026-10-23)

Historical source last updated, 2026-10-23. Runtime and implementation claims below describe that dated source; see current app notes and source for subsequent changes.

Exact inputs and review completed

Compiler standing input is the canonical donor's tools/watx-src/compiler-codegen.js, 302257 bytes, SHA256 84744dbdef3897f589f1c1465cc6d3025448250df09b1254369fdb16f73fa94d, Git blob 71d05cb80f8d87d3d879d6b1d6329a5c5eeaca8c. Canonical donor root: /home/user/wine-assembly-shadow-man-span-static-canonical-oct23. The verifier checked compiler, mirror and build.sh bytes against the canonical manifest and source-bindings entries, including Git blob hashes computed from the actual bytes. Candidate remains b41a7c5f4b752d1f0bdab1141a11d4fed4dc6f9a; source acceptance is 4dab22cfefb7b7048fbb6189b81cdccdd4ab8753. Mirror blob is 7f96dd1a81886946eb5fccefd5676c24e9016349, SHA256 1f1edfd8f13ef528434828243e8f1e37a059d2c4136dc7aaa1427b91e629e968; build.sh blob is 5407cb296ee6cdab2e30a226d1188206beb852af, SHA256 5ca2278e733bea26d8c261b993006424b845bc9328753d1b1506119e4608b5ef. The read-only build compiler contract tools/build-compile-wat.js SHA256 is ef0833c055363f71f383eee1b2d285c3521d151e8a4048123c36ba920c5e6c87. Neither compiler nor contract was executed.

Manual review read the whole helper delta, helper, retained schema/laws excerpt, new 14-method suite, original 16-test suite and unchanged rejecting probe. Actual compiler sections for heads, globals, extents and laws were read directly at the correct standing path. The automated schema-excerpt equality assertion occurs after the failed diff assertion and was not reached.

The delta introduces clause arity validation; module-level source-form selection; immutable literal i32 global extraction; strict signed decimal/hex token parsing within i32/u32 bounds; positive stride/count with exact Python multiplication; mask cardinality from count when strided or byte size otherwise; positive power-of-two slots and exact slots-minus-one value; and explicit positive extent before size-power checks. It also pins the g2w prerequisite and rejects self containment. Span handling, detailed source/binary ABI comparison and full payload comparison remain visible in the helper. These are review observations, not a passing independent acceptance result.

The compiler's early constant scan is looser than the inspector's structural immutable-i32 requirement. The helper intentionally rejects referenced mutable, computed, imported, malformed and unsupported exported-global forms rather than trying to accept every compiler syntax. It is scoped to the pinned closure, not a general WATX validator, macro expander or allocator replay.

Checks not completed

Required check This worker's result
Original 16 Python tests NOT RUN
New 14 Python test methods NOT RUN
Unchanged CS_RING rejecting probe NOT RUN
Independent derived-region controls Authored and retained, NOT RUN
Same retained modules, Python static parse NOT RUN
Exact detailed old JSON equality NOT RUN
Complete inventory / ABI / custom payload NOT independently revalidated

The unchanged prior rejection probe requires size256/stride8/count64 to reject because 8*64 != 256. Its missing mask global must not substitute for the intended stride/count size-law rejection. Independent additional controls were prepared for a derived region with named stride/count globals: mismatched product, wrong byte-size mask despite valid count, and unsupported exported law-global syntax. They include a positive derived/global baseline but were never executed.

Combined input remains at /home/user/wine-assembly-shadow-man-complete-gate-data-readiness-oct23/build/combined.wat. It was only hashed, never compiled. Required retained expectations remain 269 inventory entries (268 storage + DIRECT_WINDOW), fingerprint 9a3bc9149d58209c, 291 imports, 2227 function exports, 172 types, one imported/exported shared memory 8192..32768, no start and exact full custom payload. Native validation, native compilation, guest/runtime and gameplay qualifications remain outside this task; retained binaries are not shown defective.