MDK2 Medium return, command active and final collection context
Input: published 12a87f17971452efbbeecb88778a1bdc1f863955 and
its original decoder/release evidence.
Evidence: scratch/runs/20261104-mdk2-callback-active-context/ (RUN).
No observer/driver defect is demonstrated. The final native stack locates
main-loop Lua garbage collection. Native command active=1 is a result retained
after synchronous dispatch returns, not a callback-in-flight flag. The existing
full-rest requirement active=0 remains unchanged. No runtime was launched.
The bounded offline audit verifies the original executable SHA-256
b3e0226e411abff17ddabb723e493e95579490cb49bfe3787b1eade1144e27c1,
32 exact instruction contracts, original scripts.zip and three decoded-script
hashes, all 29 append-prefix observer checkpoints and the retained frozen
main/file sidecars. Original media remain at
test/binaries/candidates/mdk2-demo/installed/mdk2demo/; RUN records existing
input paths, sizes and SHA-256, selected disassembly and script excerpts.
| Boundary | Original contract and retained evidence | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|
| Decoder output request returns | 0x47ca79: e8 02 0f 00 00 calls 0x47d980. Five observed returns to 0x47ca7e have EAX=32768, correct ESP=frame+28 and decodedWords=0. RemainingWords falls from 11083162 to 11017626, still positive. |
Five finite byte requests completed. Neither the complete compressed stream nor a Lua callback completes by implication. |
| Original Medium command dispatch returns | 0x46cf7e: 89 5e 24 clears command+36 before dispatch. Release/flags2 at 0x46d0bf calls 0x42ae70; only after its return does 0x46d0c7: c7 46 24 01 00 00 00 publish active=1. 0x46d0d6 then stores raw into previous. |
At 4080–4128, flags2/phase2/raw0/previous0/active1 plus freeze1/showmenu0 support completed synchronous Medium dispatch. This is a byte-backed inference from state, not a recorded instruction-level Medium entry/return pair. |
| Whole-stream completion | 0x47d980 stops on fulfilled requested bytes or exhausted decoded/remaining stream words; zero decodedWords alone is not EOF. |
Full stream, external read state and later stream termination remain unknown. No whole-stream completion prerequisite for every future main-loop action is established. |
| Full native command rest | A subsequent 0x46cf30 poll clears active at 0x46cf7e. No such next clear is captured. |
The stricter raw0/previous0/active0 guard remains unsatisfied. Returned dispatch and full rest are different witnesses. |
Renderer activeInput has separate ownership. In the actually served Git
1329b1ba6eb00144ff77d4cd92a8513d4fc953ad:lib/renderer-input.js,
takeInput publishes the dequeued event and clears _activeInputEvent on an
empty queue poll. It does not clear the game's command+36. Command79's ACK
proves delivery; the drained queue, null activeInput, native raw/previous0 and
Medium effects by4080 additionally prove consumption and progress. Neither
renderer null nor native active1 is a pending asynchronous callback handle.
The early decoder stack at3664 is consistent with maintenance under the main
loop: 0x402171 → 0x451540 → 0x47c600/0x47c610 → 0x47bf90 → 0x47b1a0 → [stream+8] → 0x47ca50 → 0x47d980.
The retained stack contains return PCs 0x402176, 0x451546, 0x47c626,
0x47c012, 0x47b393, 0x47a928, 0x47ca7e, and the original wrapper at
0x47a923 calls 0x47ca50. The indirect stream object's callback field was
not captured, so that edge is stack-supported rather than a direct field read.
This places decoding in buffered-stream maintenance; it does not identify the
entire media stream or make decoding a child of Medium's later callback.
At4128, the owning main thread is slot0/thread1, PC 0x4434a0,
ESP 0x074ffd40, EDI 0x083fab80, EBP17, EBX408. The exact saved-frame layout
matches this chain:
main 0x402187 → collector 0x443070 → mark-roots 0x443240 → root visitor 0x444aa0 → tagged-value marker 0x443320 → table marker 0x443460.
Relative to final ESP, +16 is return 0x44334d, +20 the EDI table argument,
+24 return 0x444ae3, +48 return 0x44324a, +56 return 0x443085, and
+80 return 0x40218c. The table marker sets its mark at table+4, traverses
24-byte key/value nodes and recursively marks both values; 0x4434a0 loads
table+12, increments the index and advances node offset24. This is ordinary
recursive reachability marking. The root caller is the periodic main-loop
collection after the frame counter reaches five, not evidence of the separate
level() script's explicit collectgarbage(). The table's node bytes/count
and full reachable graph were not retained; collection's remaining work and
return time cannot be calculated. File thread2 is separately at the supported
idle-file-poll Sleep return 0x4515cd → 0x451f62, not a captured active archive
decode. This does not establish its future scheduling or future file completion.
The construction dependency follows the original scripts and deferred loader:
Medium menu.lua:1062–1090 sets difficulty, hides the menu, freezes Level,
arms startscreen's 1.2-second timer, closes/fades and switches music. The later
level0.lua:328–343 timer handler conditionally calls mdkNewGame(1,9), then
requests scheme game. As documented in
the original pending-scheme map,
native 0x4391a0 → 0x42bbe0 → 0x42cc80 records the deferred load; main
0x4019d2/0x401a28 consumes it through 0x42c990, whose later path invokes
Lua level(). That function clears Level, requests the type10 script and only
then can produce a new Level. These are static dependencies, not witnessed
execution in this history. Timer dispatch may occur within later frame work;
the evidence does not order it after a required next command poll.
The exact missing witness is same-history owning-main progression out of this
collection, correlated with the startscreen timer identity/deadline/firing and
its handler return; the native requested-level/checkpoint/load flag
0x4b712c/0x4b7494/0x5ccb48; then load consumption, type10 demand/completion,
script-buffer execution and new Level identity. Current observation retains
startscreen, applied menu/pending nil, completed old pointer resource, and no
new demand/finalizer/script-buffer/new-Level records. The level-load globals,
timer object and complete Lua call state were not captured. Thus no lost timer,
loader failure, stuck callback or eventual construction success is established.
An exact continuous Medium dispatch entry/return pair is also absent, though
the post-return active store supports the narrower return inference above.
Reproduction: node scratch/runs/20261104-mdk2-callback-active-context/audit.cjs.
It passes 32 byte contracts, 29 retained prefix checkpoints, 5 request returns
and 9 negative interpretation/frame controls. A pure ordering model illustrates
post-return active retention; it is not native execution. One initial audit
address transcription error is retained in audit-initial.log; the corrected
pin is 0x47d9e0. No production/helper/test file changed, so no build or native
fixture execution is claimed. Git SHA, relevant binary diff and new-file
patches preserve provenance. No source snapshots, media/module copies, expanded
historical archive, npm, Chrome, game, boat, heavy runtime lock, admission,
retry, subworker or deployment was used. All 50M/360s owner/record/byte/input/ACK,
frozen-review, 16ms and 512/544 guards are preserved. Host overhead supplies no
progress-duration estimate. Box ID/state/expiry: NA; coordinator owns shutdown.
This bounded finding completes the assignment; stop without further execution.